Thanksgiving 2026 · Fort Myers
Thanksgiving pies and bakes
Order by Wednesday, November 18. Pickup Thursday, November 19 or Friday, November 20 in North Fort Myers (we text the address), or delivery around Fort Myers and Cape Coral. We're closed Thanksgiving week (Nov 21 to 28). Small batches, so there's a limited number of pies.
Pies
No pumpkin pie? Florida's home-bakery law doesn't allow pies that need the fridge (pumpkin, sweet potato, custard or cream), so we make the best pies it does allow.
For the table
Pecan bars, half pan$368 barsButtery shortbread, a chewy maple pecan top, flaky salt.Contains wheat, milk and pecans. Made with bourbon.
Coffee cake, whole$309x9, 9 squaresSour cream cake, a cinnamon ribbon and a thick crumb top. For Thanksgiving or Black Friday morning.Contains wheat, milk and egg.
Chocolate babka$16per loafA twisted, syrup-brushed loaf swirled with dark chocolate.Contains wheat, milk and egg.Ready? Open the Thanksgiving menu on the order form, pick your items, and choose Nov 19 or 20 as your day. We review every order, then send payment and pickup details.
Order ThanksgivingGetting ready for Thursday: pies keep 2 to 4 days at room temperature, so freeze them the day you pick them up, wrapped well in plastic and foil. Thaw on the counter, still wrapped, overnight Wednesday. Babka and coffee cake freeze and thaw the same way.
Each one comes with an ingredient label. Everything is made in our home kitchen, which also handles wheat, milk, eggs, soy and tree nuts.
Made in a cottage food operation that is not subject to Florida's food safety regulations.